Comparing the top four online engagement ring companies

Though there are quite a few companies online offering to help you find the perfect engagement ring, a handful of companies are considered to be head and shoulders above the rest of the pack – the perfect place to find the perfect ring that fits your budget and your expectations right down to the ground.

And while some people remain a little bit skeptical about making this kind of purchase online, the truth of the matter is the process (when ordering from one of these top four online engagement ring companies) couldn’t be any safer, couldn’t be any simpler, and couldn’t be any more straightforward.

Check out the quick breakdowns we have for you below regarding the best for online engagement ring companies and you’ll be able to quickly determine which company is best for you. All of these options have amazing diamonds available, have different benefits that they bring to the table, and can guarantee that you get the ring that you have been searching for – the kind of ring that is going to make her go crazy!

Let’s jump right in.


A little bit of the “new kid on the block” when it comes to online engagement ring companies, this particular organization established partnerships with some of the biggest and most well-known authorized diamond dealers around the world.

This allows them to offer a top-notch selection, the ability to see your ring in person before you buy it, and the opportunity to work with some of the best and most creative jewelers around to come up with something really special and something really custom for the person that means everything in your life today.

Blue Nile

Blue Nile has been around since 1999 and is considered by most to be one of – if not THE – very best place to purchase online diamond engagement rings, loose diamonds, and diamond jewelry in general.

With more than 250,000 diamonds available to pick and choose from (the largest selection online today) you’ll have plenty of opportunity to find the perfect stone for your ideal ring – and then you’ll be able to create a completely custom or semi-custom piece of jewelry to set that stone into, all while spending between 20% and 40% less than you ever would have with a traditional jeweler.

This company has an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau as well as a sterling silver reputation across the diamond industry. You really can’t go wrong ordering from Blue Nile.

James Allen

Another top contender when it comes to the title of the best place online to buy diamond engagement rings and diamond jewelry in general, many consider James Allen to be neck and neck with everything that Blue Nile brings to the table.

While the selection that James Allen offers isn’t quite as robust as the one at Blue Nile – they only offer about 100,000 diamonds compared to 250,000 diamonds – their service is second to none, their prices are absolutely incredible, and their ability to see each and every single diamond you have the opportunity to purchase in stunning 360° high definition is unbeatable. It’s the next best thing to actually getting to put your hands on the diamond that you are thinking about purchasing.

Their prices are fantastic, the service that they provide is exceptional, and the presentation that they deliver when it comes to actually getting your hands on your diamond engagement ring is about as top-notch as it gets.


Jared gets a lot of publicity and a lot of press on television, and that’s because the company spends a mountain of money on advertising in an effort to build up more business. However, all of these advertising costs are inevitably passed along to you the customer, and you’ll end up paying a lot more money for an engagement ring from Jared then you would have from any of the other options on this list.

They do, however, have a number of brick and mortar sites that you can visit on your own to have a look at the ring that you are purchasing which is a bit of a benefit. Even still, you’re likely better off shopping online at any of the other three sites compared to Jared.

Show More